Do you think it's fair how the Red Sox are dealing with Casey Kotchman?

I think that the original players from the 2 World Series will always be crowd favorites. Big Papi was doing terrible in the beggining of the season, and I hated to see him play so badly. Personally I agree with your lineup. Lowel produces more runs and RBI's than Ortiz, and as of late, Ortiz is giving Boston a bad reputation. Youkilis should definately play 3rd. That leaves catcher and 1st. Victor Martinez can play either, so Varitek could still catch while Martinez plays 1st. But, Martinez is a better catcher as far as numbers go, and he should catch. Kotchman is then there to fill the void at 1st. Also, keep in mind that the Redsox are a much better team than the Braves, so he may not be starting on the Sox. That doesn't take anything away from him, but he's on a better team now. Anyway, totally agree with you, and hope I helped.